Education Intelligence Agency

Public education research, analysis and investigations

NEA Dues Keeping the Lights On in Indiana

Written By: Mike Antonucci - Jan• 22•13

January 22, 2013

1) NEA Dues Keeping the Lights On in Indiana. Teachers in Mississippi or New Mexico who are paying dues to the National Education Association should have a reasonable expectation that their money is paying for utilities and building maintenance at NEA headquarters in Washington, DC as well as the national union’s regional offices. But should they have an expectation that their dues money is doing the same for the Indiana State Teachers Association?

Back in 2009, the ISTA insurance trust collapsed under the weight of high-risk investments. Coupled with other financial difficulties, it drove the Indiana affiliate deep into the red, requiring the establishment of an NEA trusteeship. To bail out ISTA, NEA formed NEA Properties, Inc. (NEAPI) to purchase the real estate and buildings owned by ISTA. Since then, ISTA has been leasing space in its own buildings, paying NEA $1.5 million in rent in the 2010-11 fiscal year.

This seemed to be an adequate solution to ISTA’s problems, but it failed to account for the union’s continued budget shortfalls due to large losses in membership. ISTA ran a $4.2 million deficit in 2010-11 and was a cumulative $12.6 million in the red at the time. We can safely assume things haven’t improved.

Even more distressing for NEA is the news that NEAPI is losing money as well, reporting a $111,000 deficit in 2010-11. An examination of NEA’s financial disclosure report shows where some of the money has been going:

Electricity – $205,609

Property management – $198,752

Security – $96,316

Building repair and remodeling – $83,536

Custodial services – $74,008

Plumbing/HVAC repair – $47,671

Legal – $45,754

Monthly steam supply – $39,364

Maintenance – $36,100

Water – $30,814

Accounting – $27,908

Property taxes – $25,060

Concierge services – $22,961

Sprinkler repair – $17,655

Unspecified building supplies – $11,915

Pest control – $9,305

Door/glass repair – $8,437

Hygiene supplies – $7,892

Window cleaning – $6,975

Space planner – $6,458

These items alone total over $1 million, and when coupled with insurance costs and depreciation, leave NEAPI at a loss.

The Indiana problem would be relatively small potatoes if all was well elsewhere. But if ISTA is still wholly dependent on its NEA bailout after almost four years, what does that portend for staggering state affiliates in Wisconsin, South Carolina, Michigan and a lot of other places? Will NEA use national dues to pay for exterminators in Texas, janitors in New Jersey and handymen in Iowa? Can it even afford to?

2)  Last Week’s Intercepts. EIA’s blog, Intercepts, covered these topics from January 15-22:

*  RIP CQE. Communities for Quality Education goes unfunded.

More Than You’ll Ever Need to Know About Lily Eskelsen. Accession announcement.

Class Size Reduction the Natural Way. Demographics and destiny.

Wisconsin Victory Only Leads to Next Battlefield. Keep your head.

Silver Lining in NYC. No deal better than toothless deal.

Union of 1% Same as Those of Other 99%. Congolese airlines and Chinese soul food.

3) Quote of the Week. “America’s educational system contains enough empty platitudes and kitten posters. It’s time to fill our students with some real content, create some connections, and see what sticks.” – Jessica Lahey, English and Latin teacher at the Crossroads Academy in New Hampshire. (January 16 Coming of Age in the Middle)

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Both comments and pings are currently closed.

3 Comments

  1. [...] the decision to make the sale, suggesting the proceeds might be targeted to loan or dues repayment. Just as with NEA, the national union will naturally intervene to keep its state and local affiliates afloat. But it [...]

  2. […] Since there’s no chance ISTA itself can cover any kind of financial settlement, it will be incumbent upon NEA national to generate the necessary funds. That means more dues money from across the country flowing into the Indiana affiliate. […]

  3. […] Under the terms of the settlement, NEA and ISTA will pay $14 million to the state within 10 days of all 27 school districts involved agreeing to the terms. Which union owes what was not disclosed, but it is academic since the Indiana affiliate is millions of dollars in the red and still effectively under NEA administratorship. The immediate payment will have to come from NEA’s national coffers, which means teachers all across the country are on the hook again to bail out ISTA. […]