+ California: The Last Banana Republic.
California Teachers Association President Wayne Johnson is understandably
proud of the union’s role in extracting an additional $1.8 billion this year
for teacher salaries. EIA provides Johnson’s blow-by-blow description of the
events leading up to the May 8 rally at the Capitol and the subsequent
budget deal (published in the latest California Educator):"While
you were on your way to Sacramento, I was driving there the evening of May
7, and the governor and I talked three times on my cell phone. The first
call was just general conversation. The second call, he had an offer of $1.2
billion above the Prop. 98 limit, but we would have to rethink our
initiative and call off the rally. I told him we could not do that. On the
third call, he upped the ante to $1.5 billion if we would again rethink our
initiative and convert the rally into an anti-voucher event. Again I told
him we couldn’t do that."
Johnson went on to describe the rally events, then continued: "At the
rally, Speaker Hertzberg asked if I would meet with him and the governor
afterward. At 7 that evening, CTA Associate Executive Director for
Governmental Relations John Hein and I joined Governor Davis, Sue Burr
(education advisor), Speaker Hertzberg, Lynn Schenk (the governor’s chief of
staff), Rick Simpson (Hertzberg’s policy director), and Tim Gage from the
Department of Finance in the governor’s office. The governor offered $1.7
billion and again asked that we review our initiative proposal. We asked
what guarantees we would get on this proposal; they gave us their word.
"The Board of Directors met that night, with only one day before the
deadline to submit the initiative signatures. The officers and board members
agreed we had to have a stronger guarantee; we were going to submit the
signatures. Lynn Schenk called that evening and asked us to delay submission
for 24 hours, and then she asked us: What did we want?
"We told her we would hold the signatures, but what we wanted was a
written guarantee, not just a verbal promise. Later that evening, President
Pro Tem of the Senate John Burton called and asked for a meeting with
Speaker Hertzberg, John Hein and me in the morning.
"At that meeting, Hertzberg and Burton offered $1.84 billion above the
Prop. 98 limit, along with a letter from the Department of Finance
guaranteeing it would be added to the budget. Lynn Schenk came to the
meeting to tell us that Governor Davis approved. He, Senator Burton and
Speaker Hertzberg would hold a press conference that afternoon and announce
the settlement.
"And that’s how we got that $1.84 billion..."
+ Alabama Union Speaks with Forked Tongue. Last November 22, EIA
reported on an illegal teacher strike in Birmingham, Alabama, over a
proposed 20 percent pay increase for Superintendent Johnny Brown. "What
Superintendent Brown has done is the worst possible thing that can happen to
destroy the morale of employees," said Alabama Education Association
Executive Director Paul Hubbert. EIA lauded the efforts of Associated Press
reporter Jay Reeves, who discovered that Hubbert himself received a 79
percent pay raise the same year, putting his salary at $304,427. Well, here
it is eight months later, and Hubbert’s timing has not improved.
The front page story in the Alabama School Journal, the organ of
the AEA, details the union’s efforts "to discuss a quiet resolution" of the
Brown pay raise issue. Additionally, a Hubbert editorial calls on the
Birmingham school board to "respect the feelings of taxpayers and the
employees" and to structure Brown’s raise "more in line with other raises
being received for education employees for next year."
While pontificating on the excess of Brown’s compensation, the AEA
leadership approved a new four-year contract for the union’s professional
staff. AEA’s UniServ directors and other professional employees will receive
a $3,000 per year raise for the first three years of the contract, followed
by a five percent increase in the fourth year. The average salary increase
over the duration of the contract will be almost 24 percent. In addition,
staff benefits were generously increased, including a 401(k) plan in which
the union will match employee contributions up to three percent of salary.
+ NEA Executive Committee Candidate Rounding Up Support. Mississippi
Association of Educators President Michael Marks is wasting no time getting
supporters on the bandwagon for his run for a seat on the NEA Executive
Committee. He’s already got the endorsement of 12 NEA state affiliate
presidents, including Michael Johnson of New Jersey, Maureen Dinnen of
Florida and Cherie James of Virginia. Whether state affiliate presidents can
bring along the votes of their delegations next year remains to be seen, but
Marks is building a base among the Southern and small state affiliates.
+ School Construction Estimates: What’s $200 Billion Between Friends?
The National Center for Education Statistics came to the conclusion that it
would take $127 billion to satisfy the construction and renovation needs of
the nation’s public schools. The estimate was extrapolated from data
submitted by fewer than one percent of all public schools, which makes it
almost as unreliable as the estimate the National Education Association put
together a mere two months ago. NEA came up with a figure of $322 billion
(dissected by EIA on May 8). But look on the bright side. At least these
folks aren’t in charge of estimating aircraft fuel needs.
+ California School District Funnies. Unions shouldn’t take all the
blame for the ongoing hilarity in the public schools. Here in California,
some school district officials seem intent upon making themselves walking
advertisements for vouchers. Cases in point:
* The Los Angeles Times notes today that in the last three years
the state legislature has doubled annual spending on textbooks and library
books. But in Los Angeles there are still thousands of students without
textbooks. The Times investigation blames "poor management" and,
believe it or not, "teachers’ preferences." According to one principal
interviewed by the Times, some teachers don’t like using books. I
once tried to teach reading with a socket wrench and believe me, books are
the right tool for the job.
* The San Francisco Examiner discovered that the San Francisco
Unified School District spent $500,000 over the past 10 years for the
services of Mary Kay Baldwin, a full-time sewing machine repair person, even
though only three of the district’s 162 schools have sewing classes. Every
month the district reimbursed Ms. Baldwin’s expenses for travel to schools
that had no sewing machines to repair. "It certainly doesn’t look good,"
said school board member Eddie Chin in a classic understatement.
* The Los Angeles Unified School District is in a crisis. Studies of its
operations describe it as "dysfunctional." A district break-up movement is
in full swing. The new superintendent is the former governor of Colorado,
with no roots in the area and no experience running a school district. A
$200 million high school sits on a toxic waste site. The outgoing
superintendent instituted a plan to reorganize LAUSD into 11 mini-districts,
with the intent of reducing central office staff and cutting out
bureaucratic red tape. So what’s LAUSD up to today to stop the bleeding?
They want to hire -- at a salary of between $77,200 and $95,600 annually --
an ethics officer, along with a staff of five to support him. Why stop
there? Why not hire a productivity officer with a salary of $1 million and a
staff of 500?
+ Quote of the Week. "The strength of the NEA lies in its ability to
identify enough issues that have common meaning to its members to activate
them politically, which gives the NEA tremendous influence politically,
ostensibly for the benefit of its members.... The NEA has evolved a very
broad action agenda over the years, much of which can only loosely be
rationalized as relating directly to core member concerns. To maintain or
increase its political clout, the NEA will likely need to refocus on core
concerns and carefully evaluate its tangential political positions." --
Anthony M. Townsend, writing in the July 2000 issue of the Journal of
Labor Research.