EIA estimates that, if it so desired, the AFT
could generate a mass defection of high-ranking NEA officers from all states
simply by publicizing the fact that its convention adjourned at 4:48 p.m. of
the final day -- and that was after a two-hour lunch break. So while NEA
delegates were debating umlauts deep into the night, the AFT delegates will
be sipping cocktails and watching Wayne Newton. Today’s business was the
disposition of the remaining resolutions. Here are the highlights:1)
Anti-War Resolution Defeated. A group of delegates led by the contingent
from the Professional Staff Congress of the City University of New York
attempted to substitute its anti-war Resolution 46 for the moderately
pro-war Resolution 49 submitted by the AFT Executive Council. Though the AFT
leadership was outmaneuvered at the microphones by the anti-war group, the
substitute motion was rejected and Resolution 49 was approved by about a
three-fourths vote.
By getting to the correct microphones first, four speakers from the
anti-war faction were able to speak their piece. They each used their full
allotment of three minutes, leaving only one three-minute rebuttal available
to their opponents before the 15-minute clock ran out. They took the
opportunity to thoroughly trash the Bush administration. One CUNY delegate
even claimed that President Bush planned to appropriate an additional $98
billion for the "war in Colombia," which would be alarming indeed if true.
Ninety-eight billion dollars is about one-quarter of the entire defense
budget, according to this group’s own numbers.
The adopted Resolution 49 offers support for the war on terrorism, with
appropriate caveats about civil liberties and the use of force. The biggest
complaint of the anti-war crowd was this sentence: "We support the use of
the wide range of powers at the country’s disposal to eradicate this threat
to our people, our liberty and our children’s future." Tania Kappner of
Oakland argued that this was a "blank check for Bush" to conduct all future
wars. But Leo Casey of the United Federation of Teachers countered: "If ever
there was a just war, this war is just."
The most ironic argument was made by Jim Mahler of New York. He warned
against giving the federal government "broad powers." In case you’re keeping
score: Giving the federal government broad powers over national security is
bad. Giving the federal government broad powers over the national health
care system is good.
2) Slavery Reparations Measure Tabled. Support for a Congressional
study of reparations for slavery was introduced as a special order of
business, but ultimately tabled (dismissed without action) after a short
debate. This didn’t sit well with a few supporters of the measure, one of
whom characterized the vote as "shenanigans" being perpetrated by the
leadership. Sounds like a potential EIA reader to me.
3) Action on Other Resolutions. Here is the ultimate fate of four
other resolutions EIA chose to watch closely:
* Resolution 7, "Reform of National Board for Professional Teaching
Standards," was referred to the AFT Executive Council en masse with about 25
other resolutions that had not yet been debated. EIA seriously doubts the
AFT leadership, heavily involved and intertwined with the NBPTS, has any
interest in investigating its operations.
* Resolution 22, "Fair Collection of Sales Taxes on Electronic Commerce"
was approved. This means AFT supports taxes on Internet sales.
* Resolution 65, "For the Soul of Labor," was defeated. Delegates opted
not to create "the literal vision of the City of God on earth, of peace,
prosperity and transparent human consciousness…"
* Resolution 92, "The American Labor Studies Center," was approved. It
supports the establishment of an American Labor Studies Center in Troy, New
York, which will "collect, analyze, evaluate, create and disseminate labor
history and labor studies curriculum and related materials, aligned to
academic standards in place, to K-12 teachers nationwide in cooperation with
the National Education Association and other organizations and agencies who
express an interest."
4) All AFT Executive Officers Re-Elected to Two-Year Terms. President
Sandra Feldman, Vice President Nat LaCour, Secretary-Treasurer Ed McElroy,
and three dozen or so AFT vice presidents were all elected to two-year terms
by the delegates. Vote totals were not announced.
5) EIA Resumes Normal Schedule July 29. Farewell from Las Vegas. This
concludes EIA’s coverage of the AFT Convention and signals the end of EIA
Summer School for 2002. EIA will resume its normal weekly publication
schedule on Monday, July 29. EIA Summer School practices indiscriminate
social promotion, so you all graduate. I hope you enjoyed this year’s
edition.
6) Quote of the Day. "We need to push back those who seek to spread
distortions about private -- er -- public education." -- a Freudian slip by
Nevada State Education Association President Terry Hickman in remarks to the
AFT Convention.