Education Intelligence Agency

Public Education Research, Analysis and Investigations

 
     
Home
Blog
Communiqué
Archives
Video Intercepts
School District Spending
School Pay & Staffing
Dead Drop
About EIA
Contact
   
August 11, 2008

EIA's Special Economic System Quote of the Week Issue

It's rare when you can fit such a disparate group of quotes under a single umbrella.

Capitalism. "He's a wonderful guy. I've known him for many years. He's extremely highly regarded." – San Francisco school board president Mark Sanchez, speaking of assistant principal Gerald Courtney, who was arrested on charges of felony pimping and pandering. Courtney allegedly leased apartments used for brothels and created Internet posts seeking prostitutes and johns. (August 9 San Francisco Chronicle)

Crony capitalism #1. "Obviously, general funds were used for (the political action committee), which violates the rights of the members to decide whether they wanted to participate in political activities or not." Teachers Association of Long Beach board member Dale McVey, whose lawsuit led to the unsealing of an independent audit of the union's finances. The audit found TALB had spent $110,000 more on political races than the board had authorized and at least a portion of the difference came from general fund money. Another $120,000 in credit card charges and checks lacked supporting documentation. The auditors believe $32,000 in checks had forged signatures. (August 2 Long Beach Press-Telegram and August 10 Long Beach Press-Telegram)

Crony capitalism #2. "Every expenditure has been in the context of fighting poverty." – United Long-Term Care Workers President Tyrone Freeman, commenting on a Los Angeles Times investigation that discovered his union paid hundreds of thousands of dollars to firms owned by his wife and mother-in-law. Reports the Times, "The Los Angeles-based union, which represents low-wage caregivers, also spent nearly $300,000 last year on a Four Seasons Resorts golf tournament, a Beverly Hills cigar club, restaurants such as Morton's steakhouse and a consulting contract with the William Morris Agency, the Hollywood talent shop, records show.  In addition, the union paid six figures to a video firm whose principals include a former union employee. And a now-defunct minor league basketball team coached by the president's brother-in-law received $16,000 for what the union described as public relations, according to the union's U.S. Labor Department filings and interviews." (August 9 Los Angeles Times)

Freeman gets bonus points for his well-timed August 6 blog entry, headlined "The Invisible Hand In Your Pocket."

Reading the mainstream press, scanning union web sites and cultivating inside sources are all well and good, but some of the best labor union information comes courtesy of the commies.

Communism #1. "[AFL-CIO President John] Sweeney also noted that Dennis Van Roekel, who will take office Sept. 1 as president of the National Education Association, challenged the executive council on August 6 on organizing. The independent NEA, with 3.2 million members, is the nation's largest union. In some states, including Minnesota and New York, NEA and the American Federation of Teachers have a joint affiliate. 'His main focus is for us to consider change, to look at new models for organizing, and that we don't have workers in the same sectors we had, like manufacturing,' Sweeney said. Van Roekel admitted 'it took some working at it to accept change and to in the right directions to go' in organizing. Sweeney said he has the impression, from this meeting, that AFL-CIO member unions are moving in that direction, too." August 7 People's Weekly World.

Communism #2. "I had an experience in the past couple of weeks that really evolved my thinking about charter schools. I used to think charters were the epitome of all evil, and just created solely to bring down public schools. After my experience, I find I need to alter that view a lot. The people I met at this charter conference, I must say, are just like me, just like you. People who were simply fed up with the status quo and were tired of hitting their head against a system that will not change. They see charter schools as a way to cause some change, if only for a small group of children. But hiding behind them are [companies like] Edison [Schools] and the Knowledge Is Power Program, which are obviously directed toward privatization and siphoning dollars from public education. Fueling the fire are the people who see it as the opening toward busting unions." – Julie Washington, elementary vice president of United Teachers Los Angeles. (August 6 Socialist Worker)

Read the entire interview, in which Washington also says:

* "We are losing not only our ADA [average daily attendance] because of charters, but also we're losing union membership. So besides the fact of whether or not there is any value to charters, I think our union has to take some practical look at the fact that we are losing membership, which will undermine our base and our stability. As a matter of fact, one of the staunchest supporters of the charter movement is Colorado State Senator Peter Groff, who was at the National Charter Schools Conference that I went to. He was touting to charter advocates how to influence legislators, and he laced his stuff with the most vicious union-bashing that I have ever sat through. And that's part of the plan. It's setting the unions up, and repeating over and over that unions are the problem. And lo and behold, the public has finally caught on, and they're agreeing."

* "I don't think we've done ourselves any favors by being narrowly focused on certain issues--damn what the kids need and damn what's going on in the total system--just speaking only to very narrow union ideology and not really opening it up. [We need to do a better job] of defining who we are for ourselves, and not allowing the media or union busters to define who we are."

YOU'RE SAYING that unions have to address social justice, or else we're never going to organize the charters?

"It goes beyond the charters. If unions don't wake up and begin to connect to the community by standing with them and addressing all the social ills that are befalling everyone in this world--poor health care, inadequate wages, inadequate housing, the prison pipeline. If we don't begin speaking to power, then we're going to lose the whole thing. Because even our own members are no longer engaged."

Feudalism. "The fact that you invite a person into your house does not mean that you cannot kick him out when he tries to burn the house down." – Francis Flaherty, an attorney representing the Clark County Education Association in its efforts to expel teacher Ron Taylor. Flaherty's analogy conveniently omits the financial and representational obligations attached to CCEA's "invitation." (August 7 Las Vegas Review-Journal)

Corporatism. "There shouldn't be school shopping." – Broward County school board chairwoman Robin Bartleman. The board voted 6-3 in favor of a new policy that would make lying about your residence in order to get into a better school a third-degree felony, punishable by up to five years in prison and a $5,000 fine. (August 6 Miami Herald)

Libertarianism (think TANSTAAFL). – "For years, districts have been under pressure to enroll as many eligible children as possible into the lunch program because of scrutiny by federal and congressional auditors, as well as advocacy groups. Congress authorizes funding for the meals based on the estimated number of eligible children, regardless of whether they're all enrolled. The program, which dates back to the late 1960s, is meant to ensure that all children can get a nutritious meal. If most eligible children aren't signed up, the backlash is two-fold: the government appears to be wasting money, and advocacy groups accuse the agency of letting children go hungry."

The results, of course, were entirely predictable:

"And as more children eat government-paid meals, school food-service programs find themselves increasingly shouldering the costs for much of the food. Food-service directors say that's because federal reimbursement rates have not kept pace with the recent leaps in inflation. They're waiting for Congress to grant a bigger reimbursement, but that's unlikely to happen anytime soon in this election year. In the meantime, federal officials are urging school cafeterias to rein in growing expenses while continuing to serve meals that meet nutrition standards." – August 11 Arizona Republic.

This reminds me of some other federal government program, but I can't for the life of me think of what it might be.

 

© Education Intelligence Agency. All rights reserved.