Education Intelligence Agency

Public Education Research, Analysis and Investigations

 
     
Home
Blog
Communiqué
Archives
Video Intercepts
School District Spending
Declassified
Dead Drop
About EIA
Contact
   

 

October 19, 2009

1)  Chickens Come Home to Roost in Broward County. It would take a lot more space than I have here to explain the carnival of corruption that is the Broward County School Board in Florida. The signature event so far has been the arrest of board member Beverly Gallagher after an FBI sting operation. I suggest you begin with this summary by Bob Norman of New Times, who writes, "The School Board's leaders have, in short, behaved more like mobsters than public officials."

The board's response was to engage in selective happy talk, prompting an angry rebuttal from the Broward Teachers Union, which helpfully provided contact information for the FBI agent so that employees could provide him with information about district corruption. Predictably, the district blamed its problems on poor PR and misinformation.

The most recent nuttiness involves the union's assertion that district officials intercepted and blocked e-mails from school employees to the board on four different occasions. BTU's attorneys sent a cease-and-desist letter to the board.

The union may have legitimate complaints against the board, but it has only itself to blame. Overseeing this colossal mess in Board Chairwoman Maureen Dinnen. If the name sounds familiar to you, it's because Dinnen is the former president of the Florida Education Association, and held the position while United Teachers of Dade President Pat Tornillo was using millions of dollars in union dues to buy himself python-print pajamas, among other things. Tornillo's shenanigans were only a part of the financial problems FEA faced during Dinnen's tenure.

Having failed to do anything about union corruption (a UTD whistleblower called the FBI on Tornillo), Dinnen was perfectly qualified to turn a blind eye toward school board corruption, thereby providing some sort of cosmic balance. But not all the board's action were harmful to the union. New Times columnist Bob Norman noted, "But this latest generation of School Board swine is far worse than any from the past. This gang has overbuilt the district with tens of thousands of empty seats, literally wasting hundreds of millions of dollars. It's the same group that ignored plummeting enrollment and failed to execute required state surveys, instead continuing to feed the lobbyists and contractors who bankroll School Board candidates' campaigns."

A check of EIA's district tables for Broward County show that while K-12 enrollment increased a scant 0.3 percent between 2002 and 2007, the number of full-time equivalent teachers increased 19.4 percent.

Just as the unions fail to acknowledge that the school principals they excoriate regularly came from the ranks of teachers they defend regularly, the officers of the Broward Teachers Union fail to acknowledge that Dinnen's "see no evil" attitude as board president is a product of her reign at the top levels of their own parent union.

2)  Can You Hear Me Now? According to the staff union, employees of NEA New Hampshire have to get permission from their executive director before they can communicate with anyone from NEA headquarters in Washington, DC.

Relations between the staff union and NEANH Executive Director Debra Swoch-Swoboda have been strained for months, but this policy suggests national staffers may have been lending moral support to their peers in New Hampshire over recent grievances.

3)  Indiana School District to Sue ISTA Insurance Trust. It has been a while since we have heard any news - that we can report, anyway - about the Indiana State Teachers Association, its financial problems, and the status of lawsuits concerning its bankrupt insurance trust. However, we do know that at least one school district - the Delphi Community School Corporation - will "move forward with litigation" in order to "reclaim surplus funds" from the ISTA trust.

Meanwhile, you still have time to apply for the position of ISTA executive director. In the announcement, the union states it "anticipates that the [NEA] trusteeship will be terminated in early 2010."

4)  Contract Hits. Wherein we highlight a contract provision from the current agreement between the National Education Association and its largest staff union. This is Article 29, Section 6:

"At the beginning of each contract year, NEA shall supply the Union with a list of the names and permit numbers of all employees in the bargaining unit holding NEA parking permits. Said list shall indicate which permits are for parking within the NEA Center. NEA shall promptly notify the Union of any and all changes to such list as such changes occur during the contract year."

5)  Last Week's Intercepts. EIA's blog, Intercepts, covered these topics from October 12-19:

* California's Rainbow Coalition of Bad Math Scores. It's not the color of their skin, but the content of their curriculum.

* StimuLie. Cash for clunkers.

* You Can't Lose What You Ain't Never Had. Muddy Waters and Nicholas D. Kristof.

* American Justice. Overdue process.

*  O Canada. Northern exposure.

6)  Quote of the Week. "But it's a sign of just how much the political climate in the education world has shifted that ideas that Bush once sponsored that seemed almost radical - like testing and data-collection - have become part of the norm." - Reporter Nia-Malika Henderson. (October 17 Politico)

   

Copyright Education Intelligence Agency. All rights reserved.