Education Intelligence Agency

Public Education Research, Analysis and Investigations

 
     
Home
Blog
Communiqué
Archives
Video Intercepts
School District Spending
Declassified
Dead Drop
About EIA
Contact
   

 

April 26, 2010

1) KIPP Teachers Move to Decertify Union. The timing was exquisite.

One year ago this week, Alexander Russo of This Week in Education asked Mark Simon of the Tom Mooney Institute for Teacher and Union Leadership, "This time next year, will the KIPP network of charter schools be unionized?"

Simon replied, "Yes. If you want teachers to stick around and build a career in teaching -- which I think is good for schools and good for communities -- and you're asking them to work really hard, as KIPP does, then it's only a matter of time before a union makes sense."

Russo's question was prompted by the United Federation of Teachers' success in organizing three of the four KIPP schools in New York City. Unfortunately for UFT, in March 2009 teachers at two of the three schools voted unanimously to get rid of the union.

Now, one year after Simon's bold prediction, teachers at the third KIPP New York school also petitioned the state to decertify the union. Naturally, this has set off caterwauling from UFT, which only believes in "teacher voice" when it shouts words approved at union headquarters.

Speaking of which...

2) Virginia Education Association Has a Curious Cure for Malaise. The Virginia Education Association held its convention last weekend. The delegates approved a series of measures, such as reaffirming VEA's "opposition to private charter schools, merit pay and other compensation systems based on student test scores, wholesale firing of teachers, and/or threats to due process," and supporting "NEA efforts to change the harmful elements of President Obama's and Secretary of Education Arne Duncan's Blueprint for the Reauthorization of the Elementary Secondary Education Act (ESEA)."

But the organization had some internal troubles to handle as well. In her keynote speech, VEA President Kitty Boitnott referred to them:

"As though working in a hostile political environment weren't bad enough, we have also suffered in other ways this year. In spite of being referred to in the news as 'the powerful VEA lobby,' the VEA has lost members in significant numbers this year due to a whole host of reasons that I don't need to dwell on here, but along with the external challenges of having few friends in high places, we have also been suffering from an internal malaise of sorts in many of our very own local affiliates. We need to take note and take note fast of the fact that if we don't stop the hemorrhaging and stop it NOW, we will no longer be the 'powerful VEA lobby.' Power comes with numbers and with unity and with activism, and we need to build our numbers--and our unity and our activism--immediately. We need to accept that lately we haven't done a very good job of communicating our effectiveness to our members and potential members, and we need to make it clear to our non-member colleagues that we need them to join with us NOW. They need to help us in our fight NOW. Waiting for another year may be too late."

And what could be a better way of encouraging members to throw off their malaise and become active in their union than by... disenfranchising them?

The current practice is to allow all members to vote for the organization's statewide officers (president and vice president), but "participation in recent years has been very low." Beginning in 2011, those officers will be elected by the delegates at the annual convention. The change was approved by... the delegates at the annual convention.

So get out there, VEA members, and show your undying support for the people who took away your vote! They'll only laugh at you a little.

3) Last Week's Intercepts. EIA's blog, Intercepts, covered these topics from April 20-26:

*  The Era of Claiming Big Anything Is Over Is Over. Game over.

A Seat at the Table. And some footstools.

Getting the Message. Losing feels better when you declare victory anyway.

Teacher Un-Des Moines Her Own Protest. The three ares.

4) Quote of the Week. "We don't lobby as a special interest; we lobby in the common interest." - Carl Korn, spokesman for the New York State United Teachers. (April 26 New York Post)

   

Copyright Education Intelligence Agency. All rights reserved.