Education Intelligence Agency

Public Education Research, Analysis and Investigations

 
     
Home
Blog
Communiqué
Archives
NEA + State
Affiliate
Finances
School District Spending
Declassified
About EIA
Contact
   

 

November 22, 2011

1) Holiday Appetizers. Thanksgiving is almost here, so I won't stuff you ahead of time. Here are a few tiny tales to nibble on. Enjoy your holiday.

* If I were running the Albany Times-Union, I would have headlined this story "AAAARRRRGH!" The paper reports:

"On Monday, state Education Commissioner John King said he would like to see larger districts in more densely populated, and wealthiest, parts of the state explore consolidation to save money."

Do a keyword search of "district consolidation" on Intercepts to peruse the utter lack of evidence that consolidation saves any money at all.

* There may be a long list of reasons why certain Wisconsinites would want to recall Gov. Walker. I'm willing to bet this one isn't too high on anyone's list: "Laid-off teachers union negotiator could get job back if recall succeeds."

* Why would anyone in any walk of life express expertise in predicting the future? If people were actually good at it, Las Vegas would still be a desert wasteland and Wayne Newton would be broke. The Alabama Education Association predicted more than 1,000 teachers would retire rather than pay higher health insurance premiums. The actual number was 466.

You can still argue that it's a significant number. But AEA undercut its own argument by trying to put a number on it without any real way of telling for sure.

* The Boston Teachers Union hired an airplane to fly a banner with its contract negotiations message on it. Is the union tempting Fate? Another BTU did the same thing this year, and now, in light of its current situation, people are asking how wise an expenditure it was.

2) Last Week's Intercepts. EIA's blog, Intercepts, covered these topics from November 15-22:

Criminal Investigation Leads to AFT Administratorship in Broward. The livin' is easy, if you run a local union in south Florida.

*  Broward Money Troubles Shouldn't Have Been a Surprise. When you lobby the government to spend more than it has, it must be hard to say anything when your organization consistently spends more than it has.

AFT Names Tarka to Run Broward Teachers Union. Well, at least they know what the problem was.

Diane Ravitch Sends George Soros into Hiding. Ted Turner also nervous.

Unleashed? An NEA bigwig is "free to be me" only after retirement.

3) Scheduling Note. The next issue of the e-mail communiqué will appear on Monday, December 5. Happy Thanksgiving, everyone.

4) Quote of the Week. "A professional sports league only has a certain amount of money to give its players. Why do you want too much of that money going to the wrong players? Why not come up with a better model, something that addresses the issues of rookie contract guys outperforming their deals (like Derrick Rose or Russell Westbrook) or meal tickets like LeBron and Durant making less money than Vernon Wells or John Lackey? I'm fine with players making as much money as they can - can we just make sure those players are good and deserve the money? God forbid we figured out how to work performance-based incentives (like All-Star or All-NBA appearances, top-5 MVP votes, the Finals MVP or someone who spends a certain number of years with the same team) into the labor negotiations these past few months." - Bill Simmons, sports columnist. (November 18 Grantland)

   

Copyright Education Intelligence Agency. All rights reserved.