Wisconsin Union Concocts Phony News Story
It had the correct pedigree – a Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel story reporting that Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker had appointed former Assembly Speaker Scott Jensen to raid the public employees’ pension fund in order to cover the state’s budget deficit. Jensen was quoted from an appearance on Charlie Sykes’ talk radio show, and Tim Jackson, aide to Gov. Walker was also quoted. The story was attached to a chain e-mail sent by the Northwest United Educators, eventually showing up on the Little Chute Education Association web site.
Well, it turned out the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel didn’t publish such a story, Gov. Walker hadn’t appointed Jensen to raid the pension fund, Jensen hadn’t said anything and hadn’t appeared on the Sykes show, and Gov. Walker doesn’t have an aide named Tim Jackson. Other than that, it was an accurate story.
Pretty bad, but not as bad as the “retraction” from the Northwest United Educators:
Yesterday you were forwarded an e-mail that NUE had received through its WEAC connections regarding comments made by Governor Scott Walker and cohorts about your pension benefits through the WRS. We later were told that the reporter who allegedly wrote the article denied writing it. It was apparently a hoax or bad joke that was started by a WEAC local union.
When the e-mail was received it looked like something that we needed to inform you about for rapid action. The dilemma when receiving such an e-mail is how quickly to pass it on or wait for confirmation. It is interesting that so many in WEAC thought the comments were true because they seemed totally in character with actual comments by Walker and newly-elected legislators. Your pension and other benefits could very well be in peril before this legislative session is completed. Whenever we receive word of pending legislation or action that will impact your lives, we will let you know and hope you take action to contact your legislators or the governor. We hope something like this, where we receive erroneous information, will not happen again, but we can’t let it stop us from being vigilant in protecting your careers.
Please accept our apologies for any inconvenience or embarrassment this may have caused you.Tim Schultz
NUE Executive Director
16 West John Street
Rice Lake, WI 54868
It’s the old “fake but accurate” defense! My favorite sentence is this:
The dilemma when receiving such an e-mail is how quickly to pass it on or wait for confirmation.
It really is a dilemma, deciding whether to immediately fire off a bulk e-mail or trying to find the story on the Journal-Sentinel web site – an endeavor of roughly, oh, 30 seconds duration. But who has time for such details when you’re so busy being vigilant?
Monday, January 24th, 2011
